EU Commission Clarifies Revamped Copyright Rules Amid Criticism

A key provision, Article 17, would force YouTube, Instagram, other sharing platforms to install filters to prevent uploading of copyrighted materials.

Advertisement
By Reuters | Updated: 4 June 2021 17:36 IST
Highlights
  • Critics say filters are costly and could lead to erroneous blocking
  • EU countries have until June 7 to transpose directive into national law
  • Article 17 should not apply to caricature, parody, criticism, review

The platforms can be sued for making copyright-infringing content available to the public

The European Commission on Friday sought to clarify the scope and liability of revised copyright rules adopted last year in an effort to defuse criticism from France, Poland, EU broadcasters, and Internet activists.

The revamped copyright directive, the first overhaul in two decades, aimed to provide fair compensation for the bloc's $1 trillion (roughly Rs. 73,00,090 crores) creative industry and its 11.7 million employees.

It triggered a fierce lobbying battle, pitting artists and news publishers against tech companies, Internet activists and consumer groups, with France also joining the fray while Poland took its grievance to a court.

Advertisement

A key provision, Article 17, backed by the creative industry, would force Google-owned YouTube, Facebook's Instagram, and other sharing platforms to install filters to prevent users from uploading copyrighted materials.

Advertisement

The platforms can be sued for making copyright-infringing content available to the public, even where it has been uploaded by their users. Critics however say filters are costly and could lead to erroneous blocking.

EU countries have until June 7 to transpose the directive into national law.

Advertisement

The Commission in its policy paper published on Friday said Article 17 would only apply to online service providers and online audio and video streaming service providers which make money from copyrighted work uploaded to their platforms by their users.

Not-for-profit online encyclopaedias and educational bodies, open source software platforms, and online marketplaces would be exempt from the rule.

Advertisement

Companies may escape liability if they can show that they have made their best efforts to obtain authorisation for copyrighted works on their platforms and acted speedily to remove content when notified.

To mollify Internet activists, the Commission said Article 17 should not apply to caricature, parody, criticism, review, and quotation.

It said automated blocking of content should only be limited to manifestly infringing uploads and that EU countries should provide a complaint and redress mechanism to service providers so that their users can use it in the event of disputes.

© Thomson Reuters 2021


It's an all television spectacular this week on Orbital, the Gadgets 360 podcast, as we discuss 8K, screen sizes, QLED and mini-LED panels — and offer some buying advice. Orbital is available on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music and wherever you get your podcasts.
Affiliate links may be automatically generated - see our ethics statement for details.
 

Catch the latest from the Consumer Electronics Show on Gadgets 360, at our CES 2026 hub.

Further reading: EU, European Commission
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Flipkart Sale Early Deals: iPhone 17 Price in India Drops Under Rs. 75,000
  2. Apple Announces Creator Pro Bundle With Final Cut Pro, Logic Pro and More
  3. Xiaomi 17 Max Battery Capacity, Chipset Details Revealed in New Leak
  4. Here Are Some of the Best Smartphones Available in India With AMOLED Displays
  5. Realme Neo 8 Colour Options, RGB Design Teased Ahead of Launch
  6. NoiseFit Pro 6R With Up to Seven Days Battery Life Launched in India
  7. This Realme P Series Phone Could Launch in India With a 10,000mAh Battery
  8. Insta360 Link 2 Pro, Link 2C Pro Debut With 4K AI Cameras, Gimbal Tracking
  9. Here Are the Top 10 Deals on Smartphones During the Upcoming Amazon Sale
  10. Samsung Galaxy A07 5G Launched With 6,000mAh Battery: Price, Features
  1. Google to Reportedly Shift Pixel Smartphone Development, Manufacturing Outside of China
  2. Xiaomi 17 Max Tipped to Launch With Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5, Larger Battery Than Xiaomi 17 Ultra
  3. Insta360 Link 2 Pro, Link 2C Pro Launched With 4K AI Cameras, Gimbal Tracking and Dual-Mic Audio: Price, Features
  4. Realme Neo 8 Colour Options and RGB Design Teased Ahead of China Launch
  5. Apple Creator Studio Launched as New Subscription Bundle for Creators Across iPhone, iPad, and Mac
  6. Astronomers Find ‘Mystery Engine’ Powering Massive Nebula Around a Dead Star, Challenging Physics
  7. Vivo V70 Series India Launch Timeline Leaked; Two Models Expected to Debut
  8. iPhone 17 Price in India Drops Under Rs. 75,000 Ahead of Flipkart Republic Day Sale 2026
  9. Slack Introduces Agentic AI: How the New Slackbot Automates Your Workflow
  10. Arc Raiders' Sales Cross 12.4 Million Copies as Embark Studios Rolls Out New Update
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2026. All rights reserved.