Twitter Could Face Difficulties Showing Meta Stole Trade Secrets for Threads

In a letter sent on Wednesday, Twitter alleged that Meta used its trade secrets to develop its new social media platform, Threads.

Advertisement
By Reuters | Updated: 8 July 2023 00:02 IST
Highlights
  • Twitter said that Meta had hired dozens of former Twitter employees
  • It was unclear whether any lawsuit would be filed
  • Meta launched Threads as the first real threat to Twitter
Twitter Could Face Difficulties Showing Meta Stole Trade Secrets for Threads

Meta spokesperson said in a Threads post that no one on site's engineering team is ex-Twitter employee

Photo Credit: Reuters

Twitter's claim that Meta Platforms stole trade secrets to build its new microblogging site may be the first volley in a legal battle between the social media giants, but experts say Twitter would have to clear a high hurdle if it sues. 

In a letter sent on Wednesday, Twitter alleged that Meta used its trade secrets to develop its new social media platform, Threads, and demanded that it stop using the information. Twitter said that Meta had hired dozens of former Twitter employees, many of whom "improperly retained" devices and documents from the company, and said Meta "deliberately" assigned them to work on Threads.

It was unclear whether any lawsuit would be filed.

A spokesperson for Twitter did not immediately reply to a request for comment. Meta spokesperson Andy Stone said in a Threads post on Thursday that no one on the site's engineering team is a former Twitter employee. 

Advertisement

Legal experts said that while many companies have accused competitors that hired former employees and have a similar product of stealing trade secrets, the cases are difficult to prove.

To win, a company needs to show its competitor took information that was economically valuable and which the company had taken "reasonable efforts" to keep secret, said Polk Wagner, a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania.

Advertisement

But the question of what constitutes a "reasonable effort" can be tricky, he said.

"The courts are pretty clear that you can't just wave your hands and say something is a trade secret. On the other hand, you don't have to lock everything down so much that nobody can use the information," Wagner said.

Advertisement

Designating 'secrets'

Meta launched Threads on Wednesday in what could be the first real threat to Twitter, which has alienated many users and advertisers since billionaire Elon Musk bought the microblogging site last year. 

Threads shares some resemblance to Twitter, as do the numerous other social media sites that have cropped up in the last several months.

One element courts look at is whether a company made clear to employees that the specific information at issue was a trade secret.

Sharon Sandeen, a professor at Mitchell Hamline School of Law in St. Paul, Minnesota, said that companies have lost trade-secret cases when they claimed that employees were bound by broad agreements designating all the company's information as confidential.

Courts have said that employees have no way of knowing from such sweeping language what is and is not confidential, she said. 

Companies often bring trade-secret cases only to find their claims are not as strong as they thought, experts said.

Sandeen pointed to the high-profile legal battle between Alphabet's Waymo self-driving vehicle unit and ride-share company Uber Technologies. The case began with allegations of thousands of stolen documents, and ended with a dispute over a small handful, she said.

Uber settled the case on the eve of trial for $245 million (nearly Rs. 2,000 crore) worth of its own shares.

While trials are rare in trade-secret cases, settlements are common, said Wagner.

"The incentives to settle in these sorts of cases are especially strong because nobody wants the secrets being discussed more than necessary," he said.

© Thomson Reuters 2023


From the Nothing Phone 2 to the Motorola Razr 40 Ultra, several new smartphones are expected to make their debeut in July. We discuss all of the most exciting smartphones coming this month and more on the latest episode of Orbital, the Gadgets 360 podcast. Orbital is available on Spotify, Gaana, JioSaavn, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music and wherever you get your podcasts.
Affiliate links may be automatically generated - see our ethics statement for details.
 

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.

Further reading: Twitter, Meta, Threads, Uber
Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. Vivo T4 Lite 5G Price in India, Launch Timeline and Key Features Leaked
  2. SpaceX Launches 26 New Starlink Satellites, Expands Global Internet Network
  3. New Island Forms in Caspian Sea as Water Levels Drop, Russian Scientists Confirm
  4. Vivo X200 FE Allegedly Spotted on Geekbench With This MediaTek Chipset
  5. Vivo Y400 Pro 5G Confirmed to Launch in India Soon, Design Teased
  6. HP Omen Max 16 Review: Beastly Performance
  7. OnePlus Bullets Wireless Z3 to Launch in India on June 19: All Details
  8. Oppo K13x 5G Build, Durability Details Revealed Ahead of India Launch
  9. BSNL to Reportedly Install One Lakh Additional 4G Towers Across India
  10. Microsoft's Xbox Handheld Console 'Essentially Canceled': Report
  1. SpaceX Launches 26 New Starlink Satellites, Expands Global Internet Network
  2. Aurora Alert! Northern Lights May Be Visible as Far South as New York on June 14
  3. New Island Forms in Caspian Sea as Water Levels Drop, Russian Scientists Confirm
  4. Kesari Chapter 2 Now Streaming on JioHotstar: Everything You Need to Know About Akshay Kumar Starrer Movie
  5. Steam for Mac Now Available as Native Apple Silicon App With Latest Beta Release
  6. Coinbase Announces American Express-Backed Crypto Credit Card That Offers Bitcoin Rewards
  7. Killed by Google: Support for Android Instant Apps to Reportedly Be Dropped Later This Year
  8. Realme GT 7 Dream Edition Now Available for Purchase in India: Price, Sale Offers
  9. Meta AI Discovery Feed Is Reportedly Filled With Users' Seemingly Private Chats
  10. Boat Airdopes Prime 701 ANC Earphones Confirmed to Launch in India on June 21
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2025. All rights reserved.