Caller Name Display Implementation Should Not Be Mandatory, COAI Tells TRAI

CNAP is a supplementary service which enables the caller's name to flash on phone screens when a call is received.

Advertisement
By Press Trust of India | Updated: 20 January 2023 12:09 IST
Highlights
  • Implementation of CNAP should be left to TSPs, said COAI
  • COAI's members include Reliance Jio, Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea
  • Reliance Jio said CNAP should not be a mandatory service
Caller Name Display Implementation Should Not Be Mandatory, COAI Tells TRAI

COAI said "CNAP should not be mandatory and should be optional for the telecom service providers"

Industry body COAI has contended that implementation of Calling Name Presentation (CNAP) should not be made mandatory but kept optional for telecom operators, as the association shared technical, privacy and cost related concerns with regulator TRAI to argue its point.

The submissions came as part of a consultation process initiated by Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) on the need to introduce the Calling Name Presentation (CNAP) supplementary service in the telecommunication networks.

Put simply, CNAP is a supplementary service which enables the caller's name to flash on phone screens when someone calls.

COAI, whose members include Reliance Jio, Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea, said "CNAP should not be mandatory and should be optional for the telecom service providers".

Advertisement

"Implementation of CNAP should be left to TSPs and they may consider implementing the same keeping the market dynamics / business case in mind," Cellular Operators' Association of India (COAI) said.

In its arguments, COAI pointed out that not all handsets are capable of supporting such functionalities. It also flagged concern related to privacy and confidentiality of the country's subscriber information.

Advertisement

Given that handset manufacturers and operating system providers have control over the data obtained through the CNAP facility, this could result in the breach of subscriber data privacy as the manufacturers of mobile devices and OS providers would amass subscriber data for the entire country, COAI cautioned.

"This would be biggest concern related to privacy and confidentiality of entire country's subscriber information, which would be akin to building up of name and mobile number database as is in Aadhaar database, with third parties," COAI said.

Advertisement

The association wanted to know whether any study exists on benefits of such a system.

It said a detailed cost benefit analysis should be conducted before adoption of CNAP "if at all its implementation of CNAP is to be considered in India".

TRAI must carry out a Regulatory Impact Assessment before coming out with any recommendation, COAI said.

The industry body also drew attention to technical complexities involved in implementation of CNAP and went on to say that it is extremely important that the authority shares the draft recommendation with the industry for comments and inputs "prior to finalising the same".

While there are benefits which may be derived by the subscribers from such a service, there are also several challenges towards its implementation in India, the industry said.

In its submission to TRAI's consultation paper, Reliance Jio said Calling Name Presentation should not be a mandatory service, given the limited availablility of CNAP enabled devices in India.

"...CNAP facilities is a good to have supplementary VAS service, however, in a country where over 375 million users (over 350 million mobile non broadband users and over 25 million wireline users) are unlikely to possess a CNAP enabled device, in addition to a sizable portion of the wireless broadband users that may not be possessing CNAP enabled devices as well, it can safely be said that it should not be a mandatory service," Jio said.

Jio also explained there will be many technical issues like increased load on signalling and possible impact on latency and interconnection related issues, and added "therefore, a cautious approach is recommended." "There are privacy related concerns with mandatory activation of the CNAP service on every device," Jio said.

Given the customer privacy concerns, the facility should not be mandated and if voluntarily implemented by telcos should be based on opt-in consent, Jio said.

The display of name at the time of calling can lead to various social and criminal issues.

"Therefore, it is imperative that the consent of customer is taken before activating CNAP service on his/her device," Jio said.

Jio said it is safe to assume that mandatory CNAP activation will not survive legal scrutiny.

"Furthermore, when a large section of telecom subscribers that is users on 2G-3G feature phones, 4G feature phone, smartphones not enabled with CNAP, smartphones requiring major update for CNAP, landline users etc will anyways be not able to avail this service, then the mandatory activation is a moot point and should be avoided," according to Jio.


Is 2023 the year when you should finally buy a foldable phone? We discuss this and more on Orbital, the Gadgets 360 podcast. Orbital is available on Spotify, Gaana, JioSaavn, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music and wherever you get your podcasts.
Affiliate links may be automatically generated - see our ethics statement for details.

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.

Advertisement

Related Stories

Popular Mobile Brands
  1. OnePlus 13s Price in India Leaked Ahead of Launch on June 5
  2. Realme Neo 7 Turbo With 7,200mAh Battery Goes Official; All Specifications
  3. Motorola Launches G86, G86 Power, and G56 With These Specifications
  4. Nothing Phone 3 to Drop Signature Glyph Interface in Major Design Shift
  5. Vivo S30, Vivo S30 Pro Mini Launched With 50-Megapixel Selfie Camera
  6. Tecno Pova Curve 5G Launched in India With This Price Tag
  7. Lava Bold N1, Lava Bold N1 Pro Debut in India With Budget Price Tags
  1. Reliance Jio Leads April Subscriber Gains, BSNL Loses 1.8 Million Active Subscribers: TRAI Data
  2. Vivo Pad 5 With MediaTek Dimensity 9300+ Chipset, 10,000mAh Battery Launched: Price, Specifications
  3. Motorola G86 and G86 Power With Dimensity 7300 Chipsets Launched Alongside Motorola G56
  4. Nothing Phone 3 Teased to Drop Signature Glyph Interface in Major Design Shift
  5. MIT Study Reveals Why Roman Concrete Lasts Thousands of Years
  6. New Study Confirms Venus Is Still Geologically Active
  7. New Analysis Weakens Claims of Life on Distant Exoplanet K2-18b
  8. Viking Trade Routes More Expansive Than Thought, Finds Swedish Archaeologist After 5000 km Expedition
  9. China Launches AI-Powered Satellite Constellation to Build Space Supercomputer
  10. China and Russia Sign Deal to Build Lunar Nuclear Power Plant by 2036
Gadgets 360 is available in
Download Our Apps
Available in Hindi
© Copyright Red Pixels Ventures Limited 2025. All rights reserved.