Shares of the retailer fell more than 12 percent to $23.51 in extended trading on Wednesday.
The online retailer, which faces intense competition from e-commerce giant Amazon Inc, has also been hit by brick-and-mortar rivals like Wal-Mart Stores Inc that are aggressively boosting their online presence.
The company said its gross merchandise value, or the total value of all goods sold on its site, rose 5 percent after accounting for foreign exchange impact.
Under its new chief executive Devin Wenig, eBay has returned to its roots, refocusing on unique inventory and smaller sellers.
"I want to grow our metrics faster but I am very pleased with where we are," said Wenig in an interview with Reuters.
The company forecast full-year adjusted profit of $1.82-$1.87 per share and revenue of $8.5 billion-$8.8 billion (roughly Rs. 57,898 crores - Rs. 59,942 crores).
That was lower than analysts' average expectation of $1.98 per share in profit and $8.99 billion (roughly Rs. 61,236 crores) in revenue, according to Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S. In 2015, it reported $8.6 billion (roughly Rs. 58,580 crores) in revenue.
Its forecast for first-quarter adjusted profit of 43-45 cents per share and revenue of $2.05 billion-$2.10 billion also missed analysts' average estimates.
In its second quarter without PayPal, eBay's revenue was $2.32 billion (roughly Rs. 15,802 crores) in the fourth quarter ended December 31, flat with a year earlier during the crucial holiday shopping season and in line with analysts' average expectations.
Online sales in the United States jumped 9 percent to $105 billion in the November-December holiday period, according to the National Retail Federation.
"While not a direct competitor in every respect, the growth of (Amazon's) successful Prime service has locked more customers into using its services and sites in a way that is unhelpful to eBay," said Carter Harrison, a retail analyst at research firm Conlumino.
eBay began testing a paid shipping membership programme in Germany last year, responding to shoppers' increased demand for faster delivery.
Wenig on Wednesday said there were "no plans for now" to expand the programme.
eBay derives nearly 60 percent of its revenue from overseas and faces headwinds from a strong dollar.
Excluding the effects of currency changes, eBay's revenue grew 5 percent in the quarter.
The company's net income fell to $477 million (roughly Rs. 3,249 crores), or 39 cents per share, from $1.02 billion, or 82 cents per share.
© Thomson Reuters 2016
For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.