Apple, Broadcom Win New Trial in $1.1 Billion Caltech Patent Case

Apple and Broadcom were ordered by a jury verdict to pay $1.1 billion to the California Institute of Technology for infringing its Wi-Fi technology patents.

By Reuters | Updated: 5 February 2022 18:13 IST

Apple, Broadcom Win New Trial in $1.1 Billion Caltech Patent Case

Photo Credit: Reuters

Apple was originally ordered to pay Caltech $837.8 million (roughly Rs. 6,250 crore)

Highlights

Caltech had sued Apple and Broadcom in May 2016
The court said the case was "legally unsupportable"
Apple and Broadcom have not yet responded on the verdict

A US appeals court on Friday threw out a jury verdict ordering Apple and Broadcom to pay $1.1 billion (roughly Rs. 8,210 crore) to the California Institute of Technology for infringing its Wi-Fi technology patents, and ordered a new trial on damages. The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit said the January 2020 award by the federal jury in Los Angeles, one of the largest ever in patent cases, was "legally unsupportable."

It also upheld the jury's findings that Apple and Broadcom infringed two Caltech patents, and ordered a new trial on whether they infringed a third patent.

Caltech had sued Apple and Broadcom in May 2016, alleging that millions of iPhones, iPads, Apple Watches and other devices using Broadcom chips infringed its data-transmission patents.

[Sponsored] Samsung Galaxy S24: The Ultimate Camera Phone With Smarter On-Device AI

The jury had ordered Apple to pay Caltech $837.8 million (roughly Rs. 6,250 crore) and Broadcom to pay an additional $270.2 million (roughly Rs. 2,000 crore).

Caltech spokeswoman Shayna Chabner said the Pasadena, California-based school was confident that the value of its patents would be "fully recognised" at a new damages trial.

Neither Apple nor Broadcom immediately responded to requests for comment.

Apple-Epic Row: Dozens of US States Back Fortnite Maker

Apple is a major purchaser of Broadcom chips, and in January 2020 reached a $15 billion (roughly Rs. 1,11,960 crore) supply agreement that ends in 2023. Broadcom has estimated that 20 percent of its revenue comes from Apple.

Caltech's damages model had been based on an argument that the school could have simultaneously negotiated a license with Apple for devices containing Broadcom chips, and a license with Broadcom for chips used elsewhere.

Writing for the appeals court, Circuit Judge Richard Linn rejected that theory.

Apple Delivers Most Profitable Holiday Season Yet

"The mere fact that Broadcom and Apple are separate infringers alone does not support treating the same chips differently at different stages in the supply chain," Linn wrote. "Caltech's two-tier damages theory is legally unsupportable on this record."

Caltech has also sued Microsoft, Samsung Electronics, Dell Technologies, and HP for alleged infringement of the same patents. Those cases are pending.

Why is 5G taking so long? We discuss this on Orbital, the Gadgets 360 podcast. Orbital is available on Spotify, Gaana, JioSaavn, Google Podcasts, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music and wherever you get your podcasts.

Affiliate links may be automatically generated - see our ethics statement for details.

Comments

For the latest tech news and reviews, follow Gadgets 360 on X, Facebook, WhatsApp, Threads and Google News. For the latest videos on gadgets and tech, subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you want to know everything about top influencers, follow our in-house Who'sThat360 on Instagram and YouTube.